Overall CID rating 4 out of 5
Thumbs Up: Jerk Chicken, value for the dollar
Thumbs Down: rude service, high traffic location
Recommendations: Be prepared to wait for your food!
“CID Highlight” – Jerk Chicken: CID Rating 5 out of 5
A $5 plate worth… is not enough but we wanted to play it safe since it was our first time at this “hot spot” (see picture below). The crispy and slightly charred skin was tasty even for those that are a little skeptical about chicken skin and fat. Fresh out of the oven, with a douse of bbq sauce, the meat was ever so flavorful, juicy and tender. If I ever find myself east of Prospect Park, I will definitely return to Peppa’s for some Jamaican Jerk Chicken and maybe try the Oxtail Stew next time!
Decor and Ambiance: CID Rating 2 out of 5
Does the picture above remind you of another “fine establishment”? Maybe one that serves chicken and broccoli? With all the qualities of a Chinese take-out restaurant, from the cruddy dark green counter-top to the grimy deep-fryer, and impeccably rude service, Peppa’s serves up Jerk Chicken wicked enough for you to overlook everything else.
This is great! I’ve been looking for a Jerk shop that rivals the best in Jamaica. It sounds like this place has the stuff. I’ll stop by here next time I’m in the area. The other place I want to mention for Jerk is Christie’s Jamaican Patties in Park Slope. They’re mainly know for their $2 patties, but the chicken is great too.